Best Places to Buy Engagement Rings | Proposing during Holidays 2024

stunning engagement ring displayed in sleek black ring box

Top 10 Places to Buy Engagement Rings in 2024


Finding the perfect engagement ring can be a daunting task, especially with the myriad of options available today. Whether you're looking for something traditional, modern, or eco-friendly, here are the top 10 places to consider this holiday season.

1. Brilliant Earth
Renowned for its commitment to sustainability, Brilliant Earth offers a stunning selection of ethically sourced diamonds and lab-grown options. Their transparent supply chain makes them a top choice for eco-conscious couples.

2. James Allen
With a vast online inventory and 360-degree viewing of each ring, James Allen allows you to customize your engagement ring while offering competitive prices. They also provide lab-grown diamonds at lower price points.

3. Blue Nile
One of the largest online diamond retailers, Blue Nile offers a wide range of styles at various price points. Their user-friendly interface helps you filter by ethical sourcing, ensuring peace of mind.

4. Etsy
For unique and handmade options, Etsy is a treasure trove of independent jewelers. You can find vintage rings or custom designs that tell a personal story, often at more affordable prices.

You can also keep your engagement rings safe inside Box Sock which is a thin ring box that fits inside the pocket. 


5. The RealReal
If you’re interested in luxury vintage rings, The RealReal offers authenticated pre-owned jewelry. This is an excellent sustainable choice and can save you money while still providing elegance.

6. Tiffany & Co.
A classic choice for traditionalists, Tiffany & Co. is synonymous with luxury. While prices can be high, their craftsmanship and timeless designs remain unmatched.

7. Catbird
For modern, artisanal designs, Catbird in Brooklyn focuses on ethically sourced materials and offers beautiful lab-grown options. Their commitment to sustainability makes them a favorite among eco-conscious couples.

8. Ritani
Ritani combines online shopping with local jewelers, allowing you to view rings in person. Their selection includes both traditional and contemporary styles, catering to a variety of tastes.

9. Do Amore
Do Amore is a standout choice for couples seeking engagement rings that prioritize both beauty and ethical sourcing. Each ring is crafted with care using conflict-free diamonds and responsibly sourced materials, ensuring that your purchase supports fair trade practices.

10. Vrai
Vrai specializes in lab-grown diamonds and is dedicated to sustainability. Their minimalist designs appeal to those seeking a modern aesthetic without compromising on ethics.

Additionally, Gem experts shared their engagement ring tips on Forbes, where they categorized by most affordable, best lab-grown, best customized rings, etc. Take a look at their list as well to compare options. 

As you search for the perfect ring, consider your values and preferences. This holiday season, let your love story shine through the choice of your engagement ring!